In a Journey of Accompaniment & Service to Emerging Leaders

Twelve questions to contemplate

Written byNPHLM Archive

I’m glad and grateful that the National Plan for Hispanic/Latino Ministry has taken the initiative to organize this third consultation on Hispanic/Latino Ministry. However, I come to this consultation with a healthy and constructive dose of suspicion. If the past is the best predictor of future behavior, then events of this sort typically don’t result in anything substantial. However, I believe that some good things can happen if several elements align themselves as coincidence or, better yet, if we use our intentionality to help make them happen.

Since I ‘m a firm believer that true debate can’t take place unless we first deal with tough questions and address critical issues with total openness and well-grounded insights, I’d like to use this opportunity to spice up our conversation by means of a series of interconnected rhetorical questions.

How can we talk about developing strong leaders and implementing relevant ministries when…

1.- we don’t really know who we are, where we came from or where we are; we have no real message to share, much less to model; we don’t know where we’re going; and, worst of all, no one is following us? What, then, are we going to talk about?

2.- we still hold onto a dualistic, arrogant, selfish religious ideology that preaches that the church is God’s chosen instrument, called and sent to save the world? In fact, the church has never been or done that. It can’t even save itself; and, as a result, it needs instead to be redeemed by the world.

3.- we only have a very narrow-minded understanding of what it means to be the church; (literally, ”assembly”) and, at the end of the day, we’re not really open to other forms of being in community and acting as community?

4.- we’re still in love with and worship a God who seems more like an idolatrous, alienating abstraction, an ethereal illusion removed from this world of suffering, hope, and possibility?

5.- in the eyes of the world, we have nothing to offer, since we can’t offer what we don’t have?

6.- our notion of leadership is always a replica some business model, focused on external skills and techniques to be implemented; and ignoring context, circumstance, and the idea that the exercise of power is always an extension of our own emotional and psychological issues, whether good or bad?

7.- the older generation (with its insecurity, need to control and be validated, and its constant appeal to its own experience as the real source of wisdom and the priesthood of all believers) doesn’t let the younger generation take over, unless it does so on the older generation’s terms and repeats its older forms of ministry that are alienating?

8.- the younger generation complains and criticizes the church’s current leadership for not thinking of them, instead of being more proactive and not letting the older generation patronize them? And, when the new generations are given the chance to play a significant role, why do they always choose to reproduce the same irrelevant models of the past?

9.- we’re happy and grateful to be treated as “that church of the basement;” and no one has the guts to denounce this because, at the end of the day, we’re not here to protect our people and defend their dignity, but to keep our jobs?

10.- the Hispanic community’s models for theological education and curriculum continue to be self-imposed, shameful translations or replicas of non-Hispanic/Latino models and curricula?

11.- we continue to be obsessed with demographic “studies” that turn the realities of our churches and communities into simplistic utilitarian objectifications, preceded and followed by very superficial thought-processes?

12.- many of our leaders confuse the vocation (calling) to service with a career; and then, because of what they’ve become and what they’ve been trained to do, are really in the wrong place and should be doing something else with their lives?


As we engage the issues that questions like these raise, I hope we can learn more about the condition of our church and its leaders (and whether there really is hope or not), only based on the comments that these kinds of questions and the consultation itself can generate. 


4 Replies
Your email address will not be pulished. Required fields are marked *
user avatar


2015-03-12 04:47:28
It is challenging provide feedback to these "12 Questions", which I think is not the reality of each context, and not providing a healthy spirit of conversation . I am in favor of seeing our richness in God through our diversity of cultures, experiences and on the basis of a new people of multiple generations born and grow here in the US. We must discern the work of the Holy Spirit in the past 15 years. I am not denying some real issues, which exist, however, it is time to build, and to bring back to the reality of that whole world of possibilities that God is offering us, and if we join efforts, a vision and gifts, then will we be able to overcome these barriers and overcome any challenge. I think it's time to build a healthy platform where new generations can offer creative ways to reach new horizons. Peace.
user avatar

Aquiles Martinez

2015-02-25 22:49:58
"O las tinieblas resplandecen en medio de la luz" jajajajajajaja Thank you so much for your heart-felt words, Kristin!!! Adopting this position, although risky, mediates our deeply-rooted sense of hope that somehow fuels our not-giving up :-). I hope and pray our passion is channeled in such a way that it rocks the boat or creates a few holes or cracks in our out-date, institutionalized Church. I am looking forward to continue with the conversation :-) Aquiles
user avatar

Kristin Dollar

2015-02-24 15:11:43
AMEN AMEN AMEN. 1) I can’t wait to meet you. 2)I know all of these things. I have said a less-articulate version of most of them myself. Yet I think there is something to be said for the fact that neither of us have given up. There is still a "mysterious something” that calls us to love while remaining critical, to worship with our hands shaking with frustration, to go to this consulta even though realistically things won’t change anytime soon. I am not willing to say that the “mysterious something” (the gut feeling, the summon, the fact that I can’t not be a pastor despite that my brain says run the other way) is God. But I am saying that the fact that we’re still here, the fact that you wrote this post, the fact that we still care enough to critique: these things are hope, and hopefully it is hope enough to keep going. "La luz resplandece en las tinieblas, y las tinieblas no la dominaron."
user avatar

Brent Blackwell

2015-02-20 19:41:30
Aquiles, surely this is the “risky” and “dangerous” dialogue that I expected when I first read about the National Plan for Hispanic/Latino Ministry. It is not until that we admit the limitedness of our understanding and human condition before we can seek to achieve improvement. As a whole, we as the Church continue to ignore our own issues and struggles by projecting our problems onto society as if we hold the golden key that will unlock a radically changed world without suffering. Challenging such realities and paradigms is exactly the grounds from which the Church was built and it seems that there is nothing wrong continuing that tradition today. Yet, it seems that we are raised under conditions where we are taught that it is wrong to challenge our churches or pastors. We are taught that it is stepping out of line when we speak out in regards to the churches failure. It is time to step out and break this fear for only when we admit these failures can we begin to address them. Without this, it is impossible for us to be able to begin to achieve the goals of the Consultation. I thank you and I accept your challenge to recognize my failure and the churches as well through answering these questions, all in the attempt to intentionally prepare myself for the Consultation.